GEICO's Rate Trap: What the Used-Car Index Foretells
The Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index leads GEICO's loss ratio by approximately twelve months because auto insurance rate filings can't adjust fast enough. The index turned up in late 2025 — the same signal that preceded GEICO's 2022 $1.9 billion underwriting loss. But the scale is different, and bodily-injury severity is the bigger wildcard the index cannot forecast.